(757) 552-6055
Few legal matters are more emotional or important than a child custody case. Whether you are going through a divorce, separation, or post-breakup custody dispute, the outcome of your case can have a lasting impact on your child and your future as a family. Virginia courts prioritize the best interests of the child when making custody decisions, which means that the things you do (or don’t do) during the process can potentially affect the ultimate determination.
Unfortunately, many parents unintentionally damage their custody cases by making avoidable mistakes. Emotions can run high during family law disputes, and decisions made out of anger, frustration, or fear can negatively impact the court’s perception of a parent’s judgment, stability, and willingness to support the child’s well-being. Our Virginia Beach child custody lawyers can help you make smarter decisions to protect your parental rights.
At Poole Brooke Plumlee we offer experienced legal representation to families dealing with a range of legal issues, including divorce, alimony, and child custody. We work hard to help our clients get the best possible outcome for their case. Reach out to our law firm to schedule a confidential consultation with a Virginia Beach family law attorney.
Mistakes to Avoid in Your Virginia Child Custody Case
When you’re involved in a child custody dispute, it is easy to have a lapse in judgment. After all, there are few types of cases that are more emotional than those involving our kids.
While making a mistake is understandable, it is important to understand that it can still hurt your case. Below, we list some common mistakes parents make that can harm their child custody case.
Failing to Put Your Child’s Needs First
Virginia courts focus heavily on the best interests of the child when making custody determinations. Judges want to see that parents are prioritizing the emotional, physical, educational, and developmental needs of the child.
One of the biggest mistakes parents make is turning the custody dispute into a battle with the other parent instead of focusing on what arrangement truly benefits the child. Courts often take a negative view of any behavior that appears selfish, vindictive, or centered on “winning.”
Examples include:
- Refusing reasonable visitation requests out of spite
- Prioritizing revenge over cooperation
- Using the child to punish the other parent
- Making decisions based solely on convenience for yourself
Parents who demonstrate flexibility, maturity, and a genuine commitment to the child’s welfare are often viewed more favorably by the court.
Speaking Negatively About the Other Parent
It can be tempting to criticize your co-parent during a difficult custody dispute, especially if emotions are high. However, speaking negatively about the other parent in front of your child is one of the most damaging mistakes you can make.
Virginia courts generally believe that children benefit from having healthy relationships with both parents whenever possible. If the court believes you are attempting to alienate the child from the other parent, it could significantly harm your case.
Examples of harmful behavior include:
- Insulting the other parent in front of the child
- Blaming the other parent for the divorce or custody dispute
- Encouraging the child to dislike or fear the other parent
- Allowing family members to speak negatively about the other parent around the child
- Interrogating the child after visitation
Judges often look for parents who encourage a positive relationship with the other parent, which supports the child’s emotional well-being.
Violating Court Orders
Failing to comply with existing custody or visitation orders can seriously damage your credibility in court. Even if you disagree with a court order, you are generally required to follow it unless and until it is legally modified.
Common violations include:
- Denying visitation
- Repeatedly arriving late for exchanges
- Failing to return the child on time
- Ignoring communication requirements
- Relocating without proper notice or permission
When a parent violates court orders, judges may question that parent’s willingness to cooperate and follow legal obligations. Repeated violations can potentially result in reduced custody rights or other penalties. If circumstances change and an order is no longer workable, it is important to seek a formal modification through the court rather than simply ignoring the order.
Posting Inappropriate Content on Social Media
Social media has become one of the most common sources of evidence in family law cases. Many parents underestimate how damaging online activity can be during a custody dispute.
Posts, photos, comments, and messages may be used to challenge your credibility, parenting abilities, or judgment. Even posts intended as jokes or private conversations can become evidence in court.
Examples of problematic social media behavior include:
- Posting about excessive partying or alcohol use
- Sharing angry rants about your ex
- Posting inappropriate photos or videos
- Discussing details of the custody case online
- Making threats or hostile comments
Even deleted posts may still be recoverable. During a custody dispute, it is generally wise to assume that anything posted online could eventually be seen by the judge.
Refusing to Co-Parent
Virginia courts often favor a willingness to cooperate and communicate effectively with the other parent. A parent who appears combative, inflexible, or unwilling to co-parent may be viewed less favorably.
Examples of poor co-parenting behavior include:
- Refusing to communicate about the child
- Ignoring school or medical updates
- Blocking reasonable contact between the child and the other parent
- Constantly arguing during exchanges
- Refusing to compromise on scheduling issues
This does not mean that you must tolerate abusive or dangerous behavior. However, although it can be difficult in some cases, you should treat your ex respectfully for the child’s benefit. Demonstrating calm communication and cooperation can strengthen your position in a custody case.
Making False Allegations
Some parents believe that accusing the other parent of abuse, neglect, or misconduct will improve their chances of getting custody. However, it is important to believe that false allegations can backfire.
Virginia judges take allegations involving child safety seriously, but they also carefully evaluate the credibility of the claims. If the court determines that a parent made false claims to manipulate the case, it can significantly damage that parent’s credibility and position in the case.
Legitimate concerns about abuse and neglect should absolutely be reported and addressed appropriately. However, you should never exaggerate or fabricate accusations for strategic advantage.
Failing to Remain Involved in Your Child’s Life
Parents who appear uninvolved or disengaged may struggle to obtain favorable custody arrangements. Courts often evaluate the extent to which each parent has actively participated in the child’s daily life.
Important areas of involvement include:
- School activities
- Medical appointments
- Extracurricular activities
- Homework and academics
- Daily caregiving responsibilities
- Emotional support and communication
A parent who rarely attends important events or fails to stay involved may have difficulty convincing the court that they should receive significant custody time. Consistency and active participation in your kids’ lives matter in custody cases.
Substance Abuse and Alcohol Problems
Substance abuse issues can seriously impact child custody decisions in Virginia. Courts prioritize the safety and stability of the child, and evidence of drug or alcohol abuse may raise concerns about a parent’s judgment and ability to provide proper care.
If a parent has a DUI arrest or conviction, drug-related charges, failed drug tests, or other issues, it could cause problems. Parents dealing with substance abuse issues should seek treatment and demonstrate a commitment to recovery whenever possible.
Introducing New Romantic Partners Too Quickly
Introducing a new romantic partner during an ongoing custody dispute can sometimes complicate matters, especially if the relationship creates instability or confusion for the child.
Potential issues include:
- Frequent overnight guests
- Exposure to unsafe individuals
- Constantly changing relationships
- Prioritizing a new relationship over parenting responsibilities
- Inappropriate conduct around the child
While you are certainly not prohibited from dating, judges may consider whether a parent’s romantic relationships negatively affect the child’s environment or emotional well-being. Parents should exercise caution and focus on maintaining stability during custody proceedings.
Failing to Document Important Information
Documentation can play a major role in custody cases. Parents who fail to keep records may struggle to prove important facts or patterns of behavior.
Helpful documentation may include:
- Communication records
- Visitation schedules
- Missed exchanges
- School reports
- Medical records
- Expense tracking
- Journals documenting incidents or concerns
Accurate records can help to support your claims and provide objective evidence if disputes arise. However, documentation should remain factual and professional, with the understanding that it may become part of the court record at some point.
Acting Aggressively or Emotionally in Court
Custody disputes are emotionally difficult, but courtroom behavior matters. Judges pay close attention to how parents conduct themselves throughout the case.
Negative behaviors like disrespectful comments, angry outbursts, threatening behavior, or interrupting the judge or attorneys can work against you. A parent who appears calm, respectful, and emotionally stable is often viewed more favorably compared to one who appears volatile or combative.
Failing to Hire an Experienced Virginia Beach Family Law Attorney
Some parents attempt to handle custody disputes without fully understanding Virginia custody laws or court procedures. While not every case requires extensive litigation, having experienced legal guidance can be extremely valuable.
A seasoned Virginia Beach child custody lawyer can:
- Protect your parental rights
- Present evidence effectively
- Avoid procedural mistakes
- Negotiate parenting agreements
- Prepare for hearings and mediation
- Address emergency custody concerns
Without proper legal guidance, parents may unintentionally make decisions that negatively affect the outcome of their case.
Help for Virginia Child Custody Disputes
Child custody matters can be stressful, emotional, and highly personal. The decisions that you make during the process can have long-term consequences for both you and your child, which is why it is so important to avoid common mistakes like ranting on social media or violating court orders. If you are involved in a custody case, working with an experienced Virginia Beach family law attorney can help you understand your rights and achieve a custody arrangement that supports your child’s best interests.
At Poole Brooke Plumlee we represent parents in child custody disputes, working to help them achieve the best possible outcome. Our goal is to help guide you to make smart decisions to protect your rights as a parent, while we advocate for your interests in court. To learn more or to schedule a consultation with a Virginia child custody lawyer, call our law firm at 757-499-1841 or fill out our online contact form.
